Greek logic

[toothpaste]

Originally Posted by makedonin

By the way, Philotas was fluent in Koine and Attic perhaps, a Greek.

If Macedonian was Greek than Macedonians would have no problem understanding Philotas speaking Koine to them

I bet ,next step is to say they were speaking a slavic language..isn't?

[makedonin]

Originally Posted by toothpaste

I bet ,next step is to say they were speaking a slavic language..isn't?

you bet you lose. I never say Slavic language

they spoke their Macedonian language, in extend posiblly related to modern Macedonian.

[toothpaste]

Originally Posted by makedonin

you bet you lose. I never say Slavic language

they spoke their Macedonian language, in extend posiblly related to modern Macedonian.

You must have some huge evidence hiddden to support that..i m sure abt that.

And..modern macedonia ISN'T a Slavic language?

[makedonin]

Originally Posted by toothpaste

You must have some huge evidence hiddden to support that..i m sure abt that.

And..modern macedonia ISN'T a Slavic language?

all in time dude.

as for the modern Macedonian, for me it is multy layered language, has ancient layer as well many other influences and layers. no pure slavic no pure paelo balkanic no pure medevial.

sorry to say, but we don't have pure language which was spoken 2500 years ago, rather changed and evolved with time.


And you keep avoiding my question about Hesychius and his words of KELTI, so may be you will give it ashot with the Greekness of the Egyptian words written by Hesychius:

[toothpaste]

Originally Posted by makedonin

sorry to say, but we don't have pure language which was spoken 2500 years ago, rather changed and evolved with time.

Is there a single linguist which not categorize modern Macedonian as a Slavic language??

Also..do you have any idea about the Greek language or you repeat what were you told?

[makedonin]

Originally Posted by toothpaste

Is there a single linguist which not categorize modern Macedonian as a Slavic language??

Also..do you have any idea about the Greek language or you repeat what were you told?

what is your guess???

how about the Greekness of the KELTI and EGYPTIAN words by Hesychius.

you just keep asking but never want to offer any answear!! is that your general taktics or you reached your limits?

[toothpaste]

Originally Posted by makedonin

what is your guess???

how about the Greekness of the KELTI and EGYPTIAN words by Hesychius.

you just keep asking but never want to offer any answear!! is that your general taktics or you reached your limits?

No..i m just bored to repeat over and over again the same thing
-when smbody does not understand or does not read what i write...i just move on.

(ps go back on p.3 ,post#27 and see that i have already answered)

So..will u answer to me too?
Is there a linguist who does not categorize modern Macedonian as Slavic?

[Delodephius]

I don't know of any. But I don't see what does that have to do with this. Or do I?