Prof. Tashko D. Belchev

[George S.]

i think the ultimate test is one where they allow themselves to be scrutinised by outside scholars & to be recognised as an authority on the subject.They have to be transparent like anyone else.THe thing is that some if not all are not very open & don't wish to be questioned probably have an innate fear of revealing their secrets.Also someone has stated that they are so far ahead of themselves that they lose sight of reality.An example of what they claim is that they actually found 70,000 year old macedonian writing.It's statements like that will not hold any water with the scientific community,they would be laughed away.Also they keep finding stuff about how the greeks are stealing anything macedonian.Of course where is the evidence apart to state till not hold any relevance of any scholarly effect on anyone except on the gullible.If they can't substantiate anything it's better not to make stupid claims.We are allready lost in the credibility stakes if were caught lying again.

[Commander Bond]

None that have accurately told our story in its entirety. Hopefully some in the near future.

I hope to see this soon. I am sure that there are many people educated in these fields that can take some of the more realistic findings from Iljov, Belcev etc and perhaps work with them to give the world an explanation to their findings. It just depends on whether they would.

I know that they will not come to the forums, but even though they have had their say, we should maybe encourage them to write an explanation about their findings so that anyone of our members can put it up here for all to see and discuss?

I have read the thread (and I did re-visit it since you took the time post the link). There are many things that I did not agree with then or now for that matter, and some of what they have said does seem downright ridiculous and it is obviously not worth looking into any further, but lets not dismiss everything. Personally, I think we all need that better communication from them on how they reached their conclusions.

[Soldier of Macedon]

Personally, I think we all need that better communication from them on how they reached their conclusions.

No argument from me there mate. The next time I am in Macedonia I may take up Dimko's offer to meet with these guys. But I don't know how much value that will have, for, one would assume that they have already had every opportunity to explain themselves on their websites and the TV shows they have frequented. What else do they have? And if they do have something, what are they waiting for? It is simple (unanswered) questions like these which makes me think that they either don't know what they're talking about or that they're using some sort of flawed methodology that lacks logic.

[Dimko-piperkata]

George, I don't know what you expect of me. Belchev and Iljov and the rest of their like are not taken seriously for a reason. If their "discoveries" were indeed real I am positive the academic world would consider these Macedonian scholars to be trustworthy in practice and would indeed offer them space in peer reviewed journals.

hahaha...do u remember what our academics have initiated with the publication of the "macedonian ecyclopedia" ???
only for writing the truth obout the civil-war 2001 and the relationship between usa and the uck, we were forced to reprint our history !

honestly TM !
do u really await that the western academic world would those "claims" take seriously ?!

tctctctctc

[George S.]

that's a good point dp if we wait for the truth to be printed it may not be possible to wrte it the way we see it.

[chentovist]

Bulgars are from Pamir....

[Dimko-piperkata]

i dont mind!

http://www.pamirs.org/

[Dimko-piperkata]

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - who is he ? - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - Canadian Macedonian Historical Society - Toronto 1995 - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev about Macedonian Mythology - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev & Prof. Vasil Iljov - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - Greek Mythology stolen from Macedonian - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - Greece has stolen Macedonian History - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - History of Europe - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - Nasha Tema 1 - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - Nasha Tema 2 - YouTube

Prof. Tashko D. Belchev - Nasha Tema 3 - YouTube

Tasko Belcev Mitologija No1 joined - YouTube

[Louis]

“Greek mythology stolen from Macedonian”, “Greece has stolen Macedonian History”, “Greece has stolen my mojo” (sorry I made up the last one).

What is this all about? Will anyone translate this in English and share it with the rest of the world (or at least the interested parties)? Is this another lunatic? Is there anything valid there? Can we, at least, have a summary of his claims and ideas?

[George S.]

Louis maybe the greeks have taken the mojo from macedonia as they have no mojo anymore.
What i'm saying is the greeks don't muck around they know what they wanted they took it
lets not beat around the bush.

[Soldier of Macedon]

“Greek mythology stolen from Macedonian”, “Greece has stolen Macedonian History”, “Greece has stolen my mojo” (sorry I made up the last one).

What is this all about? Will anyone translate this in English and share it with the rest of the world (or at least the interested parties)? Is this another lunatic? Is there anything valid there? Can we, at least, have a summary of his claims and ideas?

Greece has most definetly (and unjustly) claimed much of Macedonian history as its own. I suspect you already know what our position is on this, so don't expect Macedonians to justify themselves and their history each time a passer-by like you makes their way into the forum. If you are truly ignorant (which I doubt), then I suggest you do a little more reading in the right places of this forum. These videos that talk about mythology aren't the right places.

[DraganOfStip]

Will anyone translate this in English and share it with the rest of the world (or at least the interested parties)? Is this another lunatic? Is there anything valid there? Can we, at least, have a summary of his claims and ideas?

Why would you want it translated?To again say it's just another make-belief from our side?We already know what the Greek answer will be,so why bother.Please go have a look at another thread.

[Louis]

So, these are 11 videos with a total duration of almost 9 hours, and you tell me there's nothing worth mentioning or being translated? I also see that Professor Tashko Belchev is indeed a Professor, but he's actually a Professor of... Polish literature?

[makgerman]

So, these are 11 videos with a total duration of almost 9 hours, and you tell me there's nothing worth mentioning or being translated? I also see that Professor Tashko Belchev is indeed a Professor, but he's actually a Professor of... Polish literature?

Learn Macedonian if you want to understand him.

Many articles are spoken in Greek on Hellass Forums. Would they translate them if it was requested by a Macedonian. We all know that their response will be racist.

Then again, you like the rest of your Modern Greek Professors specializing in Modern Greek Bullshit just wouldn't understand.

[Louis]

I'm Greek, so if you show me a Greek video, I can easily give you its' value (from 0 to 10) or provide an outline, probably without even watching it all (small parts may be enough).